Questioner
Sauron vs. Sha Miara
Will Wight
This hasn't been explored yet, but basically the nature of Sha Miara's madra is countering and controlling other people's skills.
He could raise armies, and she could banish them or take them over. Any spell he cast, she could break it.
More than that, at her level, she could simply walk into Mordor. She'd leave it a crater. She's the nuclear weapon of her nation.
Questioner
Why did Li Markuth make it out of Cradle?
Will Wight
He did not make it to the top of the power scale and then ascend, but he did make it out.
So there must be other ways out of Cradle...
Questioner
Blackflame Emperor vs. Sword Sage
Will Wight
The BF Emperor is one stage lower than any Sage, and he knows that. If he were forced to do battle against a Sage, he would seek to die with honor and dignity, acquitting himself as well as possible.
Questioner
Emperor vs. Emperor
Will Wight
The Aurelian Emperor COULD win this, but only if he had time to prepare. If they're both tossed into an arena without warning, the Blackflame Emperor takes it. His weapon and his sacred arts are always with him.
Questioner
Strongest sacred artist vs. a Great Elder
Will Wight
It's hard to say who the strongest Great Elder is, because they each measure strength differently.However, the strongest sacred artist in Cradle would be able to solo any of the Great Elders. Of course, that would only disperse them and make them spend centuries re-forming, since they don't treat death the same way mortals do, but it's enough for the sacred artist to win the battle.
Questioner
Elder Whisper vs. Asphodel Incarnation
Will Wight
This would be another one of those really interesting, sort of irritating fights where everyone is trying to figure out what is real and what's just an illusion.
Honestly, I think this probably comes down to chance. One of them falls into the other's trap first, and it's 50-50 who.
Questioner
Elder Whisper vs. Blackflame Turtle
Will Wight
There is no defense against raw Turtle Power.
Questioner
Li Markuth vs. Yerin's master and Eithan
Will Wight
Yerin's master and Eithan take it. In fact, Yerin's master might be able to do it without Eithan's help. Maybe. He and Li Markuth are on a similar level.
Questioner
The Abidan court
Will Wight
That said, the Abidan do not have the ability to create new worlds. They've lost that power.
Questioner
Jai Long's white spear vs. Leah's Ragnarus spear
Will Wight
Jai Long's white spear breaks immediately and shatters to dust. The Lightning Spear continues on, its momentum barely halted, and runs into Jai Long, who has to expend a great deal of his power to stop it. He lives, but he's wounded, exhausted, and on the back foot.
Questioner
Yerin vs. Simon with only steel
Will Wight
Yerin. She's trained longer with the sword, she would be physically weaker than him but not so much that she would be overwhelmed, and she can do crazy magic things that Simon can't.
Questioner
The Emperor is way more powerful than a lot of people on the blog give him credit for!
How about him vs. Northstrider or any of those guys Suriel showed Lindon at the beginning of Unsouled. Actually I believe The Emperor would kick any of their butts one on one. How about The Emperor vs. the three strongest people on the planet Cradle? Besides Suriel because she is not a resident of Cradle.
Basically is anyone on Cradle on par with The Elders, or could The Emperor handily destroy anyone on Cradle?
Will Wight
Their powers work differently, but no, the Emperor would not be one of the strongest people on Cradle. The reason the Abidan value Cradle is because it nurtures and produces extremely powerful individuals.
A fight against Yerin's master would be pretty even. Depends on the circumstances at that point, like how well-armed the Emperor is and how seriously the Sword Sage takes the fight from the very beginning.
Questioner
Simon vs. Eithan.
Will Wight
Simon would have no chance to win under any circumstances. If he started out wearing the mask and fully drawing on Nye essence, that's the only chance he would have to see what was killing him.
In any other situation, he would die unaware.
Questioner
Yerin vs. Simon
Will Wight
Yerin wouldn't get absolutely smoked against no-mask Simon, but I do think she would lose. We haven't fully seen her go all-out yet, so it's closer than you might think, but she doesn't have the raw strength Simon does. Yet. Simon (the commenter on this blog) is right about Yerin's master: the Sword Sage would toy with Simon (the character) until Simon's powers ran out and he lost.
Questioner
Eldest Nye versus Suriel 1.0- the prior bearer of Suriel's mantle. In Valinhall. Since I feel location would be important there, maybe. When they give up a mantle does that make them more or less human?
Will Wight
Eldest Nye vs. Former Suriel
They're more human when they pass on the mantle, and they lose access to the former extent of their powers.
However, this only means that he would be unable to tear Valinhall apart with the force of her will alone. He'd still have his millennia of experience and skills, as well as his personal power.
However, he's scarred from killing people so he would likely stall, which the Eldest Nye would not do, and the Eldest has the backup of the entire House.
In the end, I don't think the Eldest has enough firepower to kill even a mortal Suriel. In the end, Suriel 1.0 would probably just find a method to cut through the Way and leave.
Questioner
Ozriel vs Suriel. The destroyer versus the Phoenix! Is that the plot of a future novel? Whups.
Will Wight
Ozriel versus Suriel:
Ozriel would go into hiding and Suriel would be sent to hunt him down. She is reluctant to take on this responsibility, so she would drag her feet searching worlds where she knows Ozriel wouldn't go, with Cradle chief among them. While in Cradle, she would distract herself by intervening in a small problem she can control, and then watch events play out in the same way that some people keep plants on their windowsills just to watch them grow. It soothes her. It's like a desktop zen garden.
Then circumstances would force her to get back to her task, and she would continue searching for Ozriel, encountering a number of obstacles and surprising truths along the way.
Questioner
I should have expected that. If the humans can kinda do it, why can't Suriel.(referring to the above question)
Will Wight
Suriel did it already. It's how the Great Elders came to be sealed in that world in the first place.
And the versions the Emperor and Estyr Six dealt with were pale shadows of the entities Suriel would be dealing with. When they're inside an Iteration, they're bound by its rules to some degree. Not so outside.
Questioner
What about Kelarac vs. Suriel? Or any of the Great Elders vs. Suriel?
Will Wight
In a complicated and protracted battle fought on many levels simultaneously, Suriel eventually gets the upper hand. She knows that banishing the Elder will only delay the problem, so she seals the Elder's power and banishes it to a lesser world. A world with special characteristics that will keep the Elder sealed for as long as possible.
Questioner
Okay guys these are the strongest characters1. Abidan Court2. Great Elders before they were sealed3.Strongest Cradle characters, including Li Markuth (not really Cradle universe), Ninecloud Court Princess, NorthStrider, Eithan, Yerins master4 .Sealed Great Elders and Emperor tie5. Urzia, Meia and other enhanced warroirs6. Ragnarus Incarnation7. Valinhall
Will Wight
That's just about right!
#3 is a broad variety of characters over several different power levels--the Ninecloud Court princess and Northstrider are a level beyond Li Markuth and the Sword Sage, who are both a level beyond Underlord. Some of those would defeat the Emperor and the sealed Great Elders easily, some would have a hard time, and some of them couldn't do it.
Also #5-7 are all very close. Valinhall can compete with the Champions, but they would be difficult fights. And while the Ragnarus Incarnation is the strongest Incarnation thus far, and thus a notch above Valinhall/the Champions, in the end (City of Light SPOILER ALERT, I guess) a Valinhall Traveler DID beat him.
But I'd still put him a notch above them in terms of pure power level.